amount-of-loss-dipustes-in-south-floridaWhat Is Appraisal?

About half of the insurance policies sold in Florida contain a provision that gives both the insured and insurance company the right to send an insurance claim to appraisal if there is an amount of loss dispute in South Florida. The appraisal process usually begins when the insurance company and insured disagree as to the cost to repair or replace a covered loss. When these negotiations breakdown, either the insurance company or the insured may request and sometimes demand appraisal.

The appraisal process consists of the insured and the insurance company each choosing an appraiser who will both review the insurance claim and prepare their own estimates as to the cost to repair or replace the covered loss. The two appraisers will also agree upon an umpire who will become involved if the appraisers cannot agree on the amount of loss. If the two appraisers cannot agree on the umpire, a court will appoint the umpire.

If the two appraisers do agree as to the amount of loss, then that amount becomes binding on the insured and the insurance company. If the two appraisers cannot agree on the amount of loss, the amount of loss dispute is sent to the umpire who will be the deciding third “vote.”

Should an Insured Use Appraisal?

The right to request an appraisal is to provide an out-of-court method for insureds and insurance companies to potentially resolve their disagreement without involving the courts. Unfortunately for the insured, this method intended to more efficiently handle insurance claims usually results in less money for the insured for covered losses for several reasons.

First, the appraisal process costs money, which ends up coming out of the insured’s pocket. For example, a typical fee for the umpire starts at around $2,500, half of which is paid for by the insureds assuming both appraisers cannot reach an agreement as to the amount of loss.

Second, rarely do the insured and insurance company’s appraisers agree as to the amount of loss. This means that an umpire will inevitably be used and most umpires are biased against the insured. The reason for this bias is that insurance companies will only use umpires that help reduce their payments to insureds and courts usually appoint an umpire biased against insureds. Given the limited number of individuals that can serve as umpires in amount of loss disputes in South Florida, this severely limits the insured’s ability to have an impartial umpire during the appraisal process. The insured is either forced to agree to use a biased umpire from the insurance company or accept a court appointed umpire who is usually biased.

Third, if there is a serious disagreement regarding the amount of loss, insureds are best situated if they initiate a lawsuit to resolve their dispute with their insurance company. This provides a method of dispute resolution that provides a more fair result to insureds.

However, appraisal does not always result in an unfair result for the insured. There are instances where the insurance company retains a knowledgeable appraiser who either agrees with the insured’s appraiser and/or calculates an amount of loss higher than the initial amount proposed by the insured’s appraiser.

What Can Florida’s Public Adjusters Do to Help?

By using an experienced and qualified public adjuster, such as Florida’s Best Public Adjusters, insureds can more effectively negotiate their insurance claim with their insurance company and avoid the appraisal process when there are amount of loss disputes in South Florida. Should the insurance claim unavoidably enter appraisal, Florida’s Public Adjusters can help the insured through the process as easily as possible, minimizing any further reduction in their insurance claim.

Related Posts

Aaron Skloff
Aaron Skloff
October 30, 2023
Stephen was very knowledgeable and sincerely took an interest.
July 28, 2022
Florida’s Best Public Adjusters ARE the best. Our adjuster came to the house a few times to scope out the damage from a water leak and he spent quite a bit of time measuring the affected areas. The resulting claim amount was amazing. If we had handled the insurance company ourselves we would have come up way short. We highly recommend and trust Florida’s Best. Thanks Julian!
Erika Clancy
Erika Clancy
May 1, 2022
Stephen Lippy was great to work with! Very informative and communicative throughout the process. We were not familiar with the public adjusting process but Steve and his team helped walk us through everything and explained things very thoroughly.
Ken Fraidin
Ken Fraidin
April 8, 2022
Julian & Florida's Best Public Adjusters were extremely helpful in getting winning my claim. They were easy to work with, very responsive & made the process very easy. I recommend them highly.
Miriam B. R.
Miriam B. R.
May 6, 2021
Stephen Lippy is a professional and experience PA. Stephen is knowledgeable and reliable. He provided personal attention and was always available to answer all questions. Excellent services!
Nekisha Hyman
Nekisha Hyman
May 5, 2021
Receive a referral from a friend for this company. I was very pleased with the way they handled my claim and were able to resolve my issues without too much hassle from the insurance company. Their follow through is amazing. The follow up after things are resolved is exceptional.
scott solomon
scott solomon
May 4, 2021
The professional service we received made our insurance claim easy.
Ryan Steele
Ryan Steele
March 17, 2021
Stephen got my denial reversed….had all to do with his reputation, and not the “luck of the Irish” on this St. Patrick's day! Him and his team are very professional, responsive and caring during the entire ordeal. If they are not on your team, you have chosen poorly.
no obligation consultation


Once we establish we can help you, and its in your best interest to file an insurance claim, we will schedule an onsite inspection. Speak with one of our adjusters today to start your insurance claim!

We are available 24/7!


Florida's Best Public Adjusters

At our firm, we’re aligned with your objectives – securing the highest possible financial restitution for the damage sustained by your property or enterprise. Our team of Public Adjusters is dedicated to optimizing your insurance claim’s value.

Notably, we hold the top spot in Google Search rankings as the leading Public Adjuster. What sets us apart is our unwavering commitment to serving your best interests, as we work exclusively for you, not the insurance provider. Our mission is clear: to assist you in fully maximizing your insurance claim.

Stephen Lippy

CEO & Founder of Florida’s Best Public Adjusters

Insurance Claim Tips, News and More.


Your go-to resource for all things insurance claim related. Stay informed with the latest news, gain valuable insights, and discover essential tips to navigate the complex world of insurance claims. Whether you’re a homeowner, business owner, or simply curious about the industry, our blog is your trusted source for expert advice. Explore our posts and empower yourself to make informed decisions.